Gateway to Cable Operators' Future

BTR_Feature_Art_Key_3_19_13Multimedia home gateways are not only gateways to consumer electronics devices in subscribers' houses and apartments. They also are the gateways to increased revenues and, to a great extent, the cable industry's multiscreen and advanced services future.

The importance of gateways is felt on two levels: Most immediately, they are the control points in the gradual shift of bandwidth allocations from digital to IP. The gateways also serve as a layer to help manage mobile devices and, eventually, advanced services - such as home automation - that the advent of IP makes possible.

Gateways are the single pivot around which many important issues coalesce: Consolidating functionality can reduce capex, simplify the introduction of new services and easing operational issues. "There are a whole bunch of technical reasons that this makes sense," said Derek Elder, ARRIS' senior vice president of sales.

Comcast is the highest profile operator on the home gateway front. Its Xfinity X1 service is in the field now. The XG5 is in the prototype phase and is expected to follow soon. Several vendor announcements concerning the latter were made at the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas in January. The XG1 provides MPEG services to the main television and IP feeds to second and third sets. The X5 platform are expected to add data and voice functionality.

The gateway concept is not new, of course. Recent research by IHS Screen Digest suggests that the sector is set for rapid acceptance. The firm released research this month that predicts that from 2011 to 2015 - in other words, a research term that we already are in the middle of - multimedia home gateway shipments will rise from about 90,000 to 9.6 million. The study does not break out the growth by carrier or network type but, according to its authors, North American MSOs will be in the middle of the action.

The most interesting question isn't whether this will happen. Rather, it's precisely how the industry chooses to transition to this IP future. The keys will be to not limit new service introduction while, at the same time, stranding as little investment as possible in the current generation of set-top boxes. "The STBs originally were the bridge from analog to digital broadcasting,” said Daniel Simmons, the senior principal analyst at IHS and lead author of the report. “Multimedia home gateways are the next evolution of the STB as it will be used to convert broadcast to IP video."

The question on the table is the way in which gateways will be deployed. The two options sound like a plotlines for a slasher film: Operators can either go headed or headless.

Currently, the industry is wrestling with the way in which to roll these services out. John Sweeney, the vice president of technology for SMC Networks, said headed gateways have traditional set-top box functionality built in, while headless gateways pass MPEG signals to the installed STBs, which act as "thin clients." In that case, the signals travel from the gateway to the set via MoCA.

The headed vs. headless debate won't fade quickly. Many operators won't feel the pressure to make a commitment as service offerings and televisions evolve. The evolution of sets is particularly important: If they are capable of decoding MPEG signals and using CableCARD for decryption, the dynamics could shift. "Many people are looking at headed gateway as the right direction, but some are starting to look at the headless devices," Sweeney said. "That is driven by intelligent TVs .... People are buying these expensive TVs and are not looking to hook up an STB. But they still want access to all that content."

The use of legacy STBs as thin client or slave devices in headless scenarios may not be as elegant a solution as it appears on first blush. The installed base of STBs don't all have MoCA capabilitiesmany lack the processing power to handle some of the emerging video schemes. Both of these issues could be limiting factors.

Observers suggest that headless approach ultimately will predominate. How this will roll out is uncertain, however, due to the significant number of variables in play. Some operators may sit on the sidelines until the technology and business cases solidify and jump right to the headless gateway approach, while others may move more quickly and introduced a generation of headed gear.

The bottom line is that the debate over how to best deploy gateways is not close to being settled. "What you find is that the bigger operators [are considering] both of these systems, depending on the household," said Roger Gregory, the vice president of Entropic's set top business unit. "It depends on the household. If it is a household with multiple DVRs and lots of television end points, they may wish to have a headless gateway. If it is a household with traditional DVR service, they may opt for a headed service and expand over time."

Carl Weinschenk is the Senior Editor of Broadband Technology Report. Reach him at

Get the Broadband Technology Report Newsletters Delivered to Your Inbox

Subscribe to email newsletters today at no cost and receive the latest information on:

  • Video Technology
  • Network Technology
  • BTR Wrap-Up
  • Technology Alerts
  • BTR LATAM (Latin America)

Easily post a comment below using your Linkedin, Twitter, Google or Facebook account.

Related Articles


GCI Picks Tektronix Video Monitoring

October 3, 2015 Alaskan cable operator GCI (NASDAQ:GNCMA) has selected the Tektronix Med...
FYI Television

FYI, Axwave Team on Audience Metrics

October 3, 2015 FYI Television, an entertainment metadata and media content supplier, an...

Comcast Biz Makes Desk Phones Mobile

October 3, 2015 Comcast (NASDAQ:CMCSA) Business has launched Comcast Business Voice Mobi...


2015 Cable-Tec Expo Wrap-Up

Whether you couldn't make it to Cable-Tec this year or want to see if you missed anything while you were there, you'll want to join BTR editors Stephen Hardy and Ron Hendrickson as they reveal their picks for the...
Sponsored by

How CCAP is changing the landscape of service deployment and testing within the home environment

How does CCAP extend to the home, adding capacity and flexibility to provide new and improved services? This webinar, sponsored by Viavi Solutions, discusses the benefits of CCAP in the home, including what ...
Date: September 30, 2015
Sponsored by

The Benefits of Network Monitoring

There's more value in network monitoring than you might think. This webcast will cover the various benefits of monitoring, including how the right monitoring strategy can save time, money, and customer churn. Par...
August 28, 2015
Sponsored by

White Papers & Special Reports

Cloud Based DVR - Business Brief

September 2015 TV has changed dramatically. No more are we tied to the living room and a network schedule to enjoy a favorite program. Televsion comes with us, wherever we ...

Converged Cable Access Platform (CCAP) to the Home

September 2015 CCAP is getting a lot of attention due to its ability to reduce costs for operators and better meet bandwidth needs for IP-based traffic. CCAP will align net...

Dynamic Ad Insertion Extends Monetization Opportunities

July 2015 Video on demand (VoD) has become a consistent moneymaker for video content providers. However, until recently VoD hasn't further developed its revenue-genera...

BTR Blogs

BTR Managing Editor Ron Hendrickson

DOCSIS 3.1: Just about There

September 23, 2015 DOCSIS 3.1 is edging closer to reality - or more properly, to availabili...
BTR Managing Editor Ron Hendrickson

Feds: Broadband Is a Utility

September 22, 2015 The writing's been on the wall for a while, but now it's 10 feet tall an...
BTR Managing Editor Ron Hendrickson

Big Week for Big Internet

August 13, 2015 This week has been a busy one for Internet news, particularly gigabit an...

Featured Hangouts

Three Technologies, One Conversation

Join BTR in an exclusive Google Hangout for a wide-ranging 30-minute informal discussion of the latest in multiscreen...

Goal! How Comcast Met The Challenge of Live Streaming The World Cup To Subscriber Devices

This live video chat with Vito Forlenza, Senior Director, TV Everywhere Content & Product Strategy for Comcast Ca...

Leakage, Ingress and Interference in Digital Cable Networks

Join us for BTR’s fourth Google Hangout – this time on UHF leakage and LTE interference – with Nick Segura (Charter) ...

Sign up for BTR's FREE newsletters